Monday, 22 June 2009

Research - (Genre Comparative Study)

Nickelback - Photograph



Daughtry - It's Not Over




Photograph by Nickelback is all about the bands past, growing up in a small country town. There are a large amount of references to this fact throughout the video. Most of these are by using the link between the lyrics and the visuals. The first of these links is when Chad Kroeger, the lead singer of Nickelback sings, “this is where I grew up”, during this part of the song, Chad Kroeger is standing outside an old house and because of the lyrics, you understand that that was where he grew up. Another link is in the next verse, when Chad Kroeger sings “this is where I went to school”, which just like the last link, he is standing outside a school building. This could again suggest to the audience that this was his old school. There are also other links between the lyrics and visuals, which don't refer as much to the bands past. The first is at the beginning of the song, when Chad Kroeger sings “Look at this photograph”. When this is being sung, he is the only person in the shot and he is holding up an old photo to the camera. Another link is situated towards the end of the song, when “I miss that town” is sung, and shots of the town are played throughout that small verse.

It's Not Over by Daughtry is telling the story of a man, who is trying to rebuild his life after being released from prison. There are no direct links between small parts of the lyrics and visuals, but you could say that the lyrics as a whole and the music video are similar. This is because Chris Daughtry, the lead singer, is singing the lyrics on behalf of the man in the video, and the video is showing us his fight to rebuild his life while the lyrics are being sung. This is really one of the two differences between the two music videos. The other difference is that in Photograph, the band is performing within the narrative, whereas, in It's Not Over, there is a separate narrative within the music video.

Although there are differences between the two music videos, there are also some similarities.

One of these similarities is in the links between the music and the visuals. In Nickelback's Photograph, there is a steady pace to the shot transitions throughout the video, until the chorus is played. This is when the shots start to ascend in pace, so much so that it starts to become almost montage like, with shots of the band performing and also shots of the narrative. During the chorus is not only the time when the shot pace increases. It also happens when the music pace increases. This is the same case in It's Not Over by Daughtry. When the chorus starts, and the music pace increases, so does the pace of the shot transitions.

Another similarity between Photograph and It's Not Over is by the way they use promotion throughout their videos. They are similar in the fact that both are only promoting the band and the song, and not a film or movie, so no intertextuality is present. Both videos promote the band in one way, by continually showing shots of the band throughout the entire video sequence, shots either containing just one band member, groups of band members or the band as a whole. Normally, in these shots, the band members will be playing their instruments, just to show the audience their talents.

Overall, Photograph by Nickelback and It’s Not Over by Daughtry are two music videos that follow the generic conventions of the rock genre, however, even though they are both songs of the same genre, there are a few differences within the videos, but then again, not many songs are completely similar nowadays, due to the ever growing technologies that are available today.

No comments:

Post a Comment